“Phase 1” Of Potemkin Trade Deal Signed, Sealed, And Yet To Deliver


We have been busy collecting bets on the outcome of the U.S.-China Trade Deal.

We never believed for one moment that China would cave on any of the big issues, such as restructuring its economy and any deal would be just some token political salad dressing for the 2020 election.  Most importantly, it moves the needle very little in bringing jobs back to the U.S. rust belt as promised.  The global manufacturing sector is in recession — though appears to be putting in a bottom —  as a result of the administration’s trade policy and the U.S. farm belt has been devastated and may never fully recover.

But. if you know the trip to Disneyland is coming to end, its always best to stay in Fantasyland as long as possible.

So, after all the American economic carnage caused by Trump’s trade war, is the administration about to, or willing to cave on what they said were the most important issues:  1) intellectual property protection, 2) industrial policy reform?

Will Trump cut another meaningless Potemkin Trade Deal?  – GMM, Nov ’19


Moreover, much of the deal depends on whether the Chinese will abide by Soviet-style import quotas.  Whatever happened to free markets?  Import quotas and managed trade are about as a socialist economic policy there is,  folks, except for maybe nationalizing the “commanding heights” of the economy.

We also thought “Socialism” was a big trigger word in the U.S. body politic?

But, hey, it is 1984-ish out there and even most golfers do not believe the USGA handicap system is tantamount to welfare.  In our local skins games,  the first question we ask our opponents upon moving to the next tee box is, “how many food stamps do you get on this hole.”  We do not disparage those on SNAP “as there but by the Grace of God go we.”

The deal has caused lots of pain with little gain, much like the USMCA — though USMCA was more diplomatic than economic pain as there is very little difference in NAFTA and NAFTA 2.0 (USMCA).

World Is Still Worse Off

The world — not stockholders — is worse off today than when the tariff war began as illustrated by the Peterson Institute for International Economics (PIIE) charts below.   Mr. Market was surprised yesterday that the tariffs are remaining in place?  Now that’s efficient but not surprising as he is going through one of those phases experienced about every ten years.

We are thankful, however,  the economic hostilities have momentarily ratcheted down but the game is hardly over.

We hope the World Trade Organization will reinvent itself, strip China of its developing country status, which allows for special and differential treatment, and we move back from the brink to a rules-based global trading system.

Dog Food

The following excerpt from the text of the deal exemplifies our perception:


How many S&P points is the above paragraph worth?

Both parties will begin discussions on China’s imports of, say, dog food?

Seriously, after more than two years of negotiations, they couldn’t even agree on dog and cat food imports?   

We fear tariffs are the new paranormal.


Source:  PIIE





This entry was posted in Trade War, Uncategorized and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.