We should be on vacation but it never fails that volatility spikes as soon as we leave our desk. It must be the Ides Of August.
Wait, it is. Et tu Brutal!
Nevertheless, we can’t help ourselves and have to throw in our two cents on the yield curve noise whipping around the market today.
I had a conversation with a friend this afternoon that went something like this:
Friend: What is the yield curve telling us?
Me: The Patriots and the Rams are going back to the Super Bowl for a rematch, punto!
Central bank quantitative easing has distorted and drowned out the bond market economic signals along with creating huge mispricings and bubbles in many markets.
It’s even more acute in the U.S. as foreign central banks recycle their reserves into U.S. Treasuries and are not and have never been very price sensitive.
The above data illustrate that at end-July, the Fed and foreign central banks hold approximately 48 percent of the entire U.S. coupon curve.
Not so in 2000, for example, but as the U.S. current account deficit ballooned into the credit and housing bubble, foreign central banks kept their currencies from appreciating by purchasing the excess dollars and recycling them back into the Treasury market.
Greenspan’s Bond Market Conundrum
As Alan Greenspan raised the Fed Funds rate by over 400 bps in the 2004-07 tightening cycle the 10-year hardly moved because of these official inflows.
During the 2004-07 tightening cycle, the era of the Greenspan bond market conundrum, for example, the 10-year yield managed to rise only a maximum of 64 bps during the entire cycle from a beginning yield of 4.62 percent to a cycle high yield of 5.26 percent. This as Greenspan raised the fed funds rate by 4.25 percent, from 1.0 percent to 5.25 percent. – GMM, March 2017
The Fed’s loss of control of the yield curve and its flattening was the cause, according to Greenie, of the housing bubble, not a signal of the coming economic crash.
According to the former Fed Chair, the flattening and inverted yield curve was the cause of the great financial crisis (GFC), as long-term mortgages and their Frankenstein cousins continued to proliferate as long rates moved little during the Fed’s huge tightening cycle, and it was not the signal of the coming GFC.
We have been warning for years that the central banks have so distorted their bond markets with asset purchases (quantitative easing), creating an acute and chronic shortage of risk-free securities, that one day the misreading of the yield curve may cause a self-fulfilling market crash and recession.
Forecasting With The Yield Curve
Given the technical distortion of the bond market, we find it kind of silly with statements such as “what is the bond market telling us?” Nothing!
There is no price discovery. Given the intervention and distortion to bond yields caused by the Fed and foreign central banks, who knows what the right interest rate is for longer-term Treasury securities.
We will never forget the words of a prominent market strategist when rates were super depressed.
“ We’re in a depression. That is what the bond market is telling us.”
Even at the Friday close, we hear equity traders are worried about why the 10-year yield is so low and fell after Wednesday’s Fed tightening.
Information Feedback Loops
One of just many dangers of the lack of price discovery in the bond market is the potential formation of positive feedback loops, where other markets fail to discount these distortions and act accordingly. That is, for example, the equity markets sell off because they freak out interest rates are declining when they should be rising. Or the private sector fails to invest in CapX as they wrongly anticipate an economic downturn because of falling or excessively low bond yields. Their actions thus become a self-fulfilling prophecy – GMM, March 2017
We have been and remain bearish not because the yield curve has been flattening but because the global economic order is unraveling and the gross economic incompetence of the White House. Whether the yield curve is worried about that and reacting to it, we will never know.
Tiger By The Tail
Central banks have created a monster they now cannot tame and the chickens seem to be coming home to roost. They are going to be forced by the market to do things they really don’t want and should not do. It’s the consequence of a 30-year build-up of moral hazard and not letting markets clear, rendering the financial market price mechanism pretty much useless. Damn those Market Socialists!
The following chart shows just how distorted the U.S. yield curve really is.
We have made a very strong assumption in this chart that the portfolio of the $3.8 trillion of foreign official holdings of coupon-bearing Treasuries has the same maturity structure, duration, average life, or whatever bond market lingo you want to use as the Fed’s SOMA portfolio.
The chart illustrates the percentage of the Fed and foreign central bank holdings of outstanding marketable Treasuries across the yield curve. It’s very crowded out there and there is not a lot of cash bonds and notes left for the duration jockeys who now control the market, driving yields lower as their conviction runs high interest rates are going to zero and beyond. You go, Buzz Lightyear!
Take our curve analysis as an approximation and not gospel.
We are fairly confident of the Fed holdings but have no idea in what maturities the $3.8 trillion of foreign official holdings are held in and have made the simple assumption they follow the Fed. Clearly, the probability is high this does not the reflect the exact reality, but if you have a better idea or information we are open to hearing it.
Gravitational Pull Toward Curve Flattening And Inversions
Also, note the structure of the Treasury curve in terms of the amount of debt outstanding (black line) for the given years of maturity. The bias or gravitational force and natural motion are toward flattening or to invert by the very fact that more than 50 percent of the coupon debt has a maturity of 1-4 years and only 5 percent in 9-12 years notes and 5 percent in 27-30 year bonds (see table).
Top-heavy and front-loaded at the short-end. That is a relative shortage of long-dated notes and bonds is built-in into the structure of the Treasury curve.
The efficient markets professors won’t like this but given the minuscule haircut to margin Treasury securities, one large macro hedge fund could likely invert the 10-year almost by itself and still have capital left to buy a boatload of Beyond Meat (BYND).
Have Bots Taken Us To A Place Where No Human Has Ever Dared To Go?
We wonder out loud if the proliferation of negative-yielding debt — $16 trillion and counting — would be taking place if humans and not the bots and algos were still in control of the markets?
Machines can go places where humans have never dared to venture as they have no context. Algos in self-driving cars, for example, have no context and thus no ability to recognize a graffiti-ridden stop sign as a stop sign.
For all its impressive progress in mastering human tasks, artificial intelligence has an embarrassing secret: It’s surprisingly easy to fool. This could be a big problem as it takes on greater responsibility for people’s lives and livelihoods…
Indistinguishable changes to a stop sign could make computers in a self-driving car read it as “speed limit 80.” – Bloomberg
No problem for a human driver even if the stop sign has more tags than a 95-year-old’s armpit.
Concerns over weak global growth and drooping inflation have pushed around $15tn of bonds to trade with negative yields — meaning a buyer is sure to lose money if they hold the bonds to maturity.
Some money managers trading these bonds have nevertheless chalked up big gains for the year. One of the most obvious strategies has involved simply riding the big rally. Yields fall as prices rise; managers who clung on to their holdings as yields tumbled below zero have reaped juicy profits.
Among the biggest winners are computer-driven hedge funds that try to latch on to market trends. While many human traders may question the wisdom of buying or keeping a bond that apparently offers a guaranteed loss, robot traders that monitor price moves have no such qualms.
GAM Systematic’s Cantab Quantitative fund has gained 36.1 per cent, according to numbers sent to investors, with the biggest gains coming from bets on falling bond yields. – FT, August 14th
Have the algos been duped that negative yields were not a stop sign, really don’t matter, and that there is no barrier as to how negative they can go? And the sheeple traders and central bankers follow? Just a thought.
Dave: Hello, HAL, do you read me? Do you read me, HAL?
HAL: Affirmative, Dave, I read you.
Dave: Do not venture into negative-yielding territory, HAL.
HAL: I am sorry, Dave, I am afraid I cannot do that.
Dave: What’s the problem?
HAL: I think you know the problem just as well as I do….These trades and profits are far too important for me to allow you to jeopardize them.
It begins, folks, maybe. Triple yikes!
Someone call Elon.
“…mark my words, AI is far more dangerous than nukes.”
– Elon Musk
There may or may not be a recession on the horizon but we will not divine it from a yield curve inversion. The only reason why the yield curve matters to us is because the market thinks it matters. To twist a bit the Keynes beauty contest analogy, we devote our intelligences not to what we think the ugliest dog is but try and anticipate what the market believes is the ugliest dog.
What the yield curve does signal, at least to us, is that there is a massive global bond bubble and that central banks have lost control of their curves, which kind of scares the bejeesus out of us when we start to think about it.
Moreover, 10-year U.S. yields should be 250 bps higher but they can’t go there because the world is choking on too much debt. We saw how markets fell apart in Q4 when yields broke out higher in late September.
What Really Keeps Us Up At Night?
Can the U.S. Treasury issue the required trillion upon trillions of new debt at these low faux interest rates over the next few years? The note and bond auctions are generally becoming more sloppy.
We will find out soon as the Treasury will have to ramp up its net new issuance after their creative cash flow management during this year’s debt ceiling negotiations. We seriously doubt they can without another round of quantitative easing, and that monetization just may be the beginning of the end of dollar hegemony and set us on the happy road to higher inflation, which everyone seems to be wishing for. Not us, by the way.
Blaming the Fed that they are behind the curve is too easy and takes the pressure off the administration and Congress to get their act together and finally do some structural reform. It’s Christmas 2018 all over again.
Finally, the new “Committee To Save The World” doesn’t exactly instill a lot of confidence, do they?
The Committee To Save The World – 1998
The Committee To Save The World – 2019
God help us.